The house usually wins

What's a collector booster box really worth when you crack it?

Pick any Magic: The Gathering set. We simulate opening its collector boosters using Wizards' published collation, price every card at live TCGplayer rates, and show the expected value, the odds of breaking even, and exactly how the math favors keeping it sealed.

Sets analyzed
49
established collector sets
Boxes that lose money to crack
49
of 49
Average return when cracked
−53%
Worst offender
LTR-SE
−75%

Crack-it-open leaderboard

Return · worst first
#
1The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth (Special Edition)LTR-SE · 2023$6,835$1,714−75%2Phyrexia: All Will Be OneONE · 2023$1,035$261−75%3Innistrad: Crimson VowVOW · 2021$323$82.25−75%4Innistrad: Midnight HuntMID · 2021$259$68.42−74%5The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earthLTR · 2023$1,800$514−71%6BloomburrowBLB · 2024$1,350$387−71%7Throne of EldraineELD · 2019$420$123−71%8Duskmourn: House of HorrorDSK · 2024$780$255−67%9The Brothers' WarBRO · 2022$700$235−66%10The Lost Caverns of IxalanLCI · 2023$1,146$392−66%11AetherdriftDFT · 2025$300$105−65%12Secrets of StrixhavenSOS · 2026$490$173−65%13Kamigawa: Neon DynastyNEO · 2022$611$218−64%14Adventures in the Forgotten RealmsAFR · 2021$390$148−62%15Lorwyn EclipsedECL · 2026$400$152−62%16Wilds of EldraineWOE · 2023$916$350−62%17March of the MachineMOM · 2023$840$328−61%18Theros Beyond DeathTHB · 2020$380$149−61%19Dominaria UnitedDMU · 2022$390$168−57%20Core Set 2021M21 · 2020$446$195−56%21Streets of New CapennaSNC · 2022$290$128−56%22Innistrad RemasteredINR · 2025$478$216−55%23Commander LegendsCMR · 2020$770$353−54%24Reality FractureFRA · 2026$363$167−54%25Teenage Mutant Ninja TurtlesTMT · 2026$412$192−54%26Outlaws of Thunder JunctionOTJ · 2024$475$223−53%27Ravnica RemasteredRVR · 2024$1,044$493−53%28KaldheimKHM · 2021$370$178−52%29Assassin's CreedACR · 2024$527$258−51%30FoundationsFDN · 2024$800$394−51%31Marvel's Spider-ManSPM · 2025$384$197−49%32Zendikar RisingZNR · 2020$429$220−49%33March of the Machine: The AftermathMAT · 2023$279$143−49%34Modern Horizons 3MH3 · 2024$920$507−45%35Edge of EternitiesEOE · 2025$704$391−45%36Dominaria RemasteredDMR · 2023$547$306−44%37Tarkir: DragonstormTDM · 2025$505$296−41%38Ikoria: Lair of BehemothsIKO · 2020$656$386−41%39Double Masters 20222X2 · 2022$462$275−40%40Strixhaven: School of MagesSTX · 2021$584$350−40%41Commander MastersCMM · 2023$500$302−40%42Final FantasyFIN · 2025$1,539$944−39%43Modern Horizons 2MH2 · 2021$637$415−35%44Marvel Super HeroesMSH · 2026$400$261−35%45Murders at Karlov ManorMKM · 2024$380$250−34%46Avatar: The Last AirbenderTLA · 2025$450$311−31%47The HobbitHOB · 2026$540$374−31%48Star TrekTRK · 2026$370$263−29%49Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's GateCLB · 2022$610$449−26%

“EV” is the expected total card value from opening every pack in the box, with each card valued at the lowest real market price (TCGplayer or Cardmarket). “Median” is the middle simulated box — half of boxes fall below this, so it's the more honest “typical experience” number. “% Profit” is the share of simulated boxes that clear the sealed box cost. “% > EV” is the share that beat the mean; when it drops well below 50% you're looking at a chase-pull tail (a few lottery hits carrying the average). “Return” compares EV to the current sealed box price (TCG low). Click any set for a full breakdown and a live pack simulator.

Biggest losers if you crack

Expected loss per box (sealed price minus cracked EV). These are the sets where keeping it sealed hurts the least compared to opening.